A subtler, funnier "Spandrels"

Submitted by drupaladmin on 17 November 2011.

Ace evolutionary biologist and blogger Jeremy Yoder pops up in the comments on my post taking down "Spandrels of San Marco," pointing us to a 1983 paper by Norman Ellstrand that makes the same point as Gould and Lewontin, but in a much funnier and more subtle way.

I should probably take some lessons in scientific rhetoric from Ellstrand. I just had an ms based on my zombie ideas post rejected, in part because the referees found the language off-putting and arrogant. I still believe it was appropriate for me to include rhetoric in the ms, for reasons discussed here. But I'm wondering if perhaps I should've chosen a rhetorical "rapier", a la Ellstrand, rather than a "chainsaw".

Categories: 
Just for fun